Skip to main content

The Accelerating Madness of the Republican Nominee

 

Of all the egregious failures our mainstream media has subjected us to in recent months, perhaps none was more egregious than its refusal to distinguish which candidate was cognitively impaired, and which one wasn’t.

In the press, Joe Biden’s age issues were permanently on the front burner, while Donald Trump’s were, as usual, barely mentioned. Once again, the media gave Trump a pass, despite unmistakable signs that he was teetering on the brink of dementia, and may have already fallen in.

The public evidence of this has been massive, and there were plenty of people outside the mainstream media who were screaming about it, even as early as two years ago. But, as this did not comport with the both-sides narrative, the story was always that Biden was senile, while Trump was just your typical presidential candidate, felony convictions notwithstanding.

In the psychology community, it’s considered a big ethical no-no to diagnose public figures from afar, no matter how impaired they may appear. This I can understand, up to a point.

That point is surely reached when the public figure in question controls, let’s say, the nuclear codes.

Now, I don’t mean to question the ethical standards that a professional community imposes on itself. Nor do I regard amateur shrinkery as an exact science.

But this is an emergency, and the reticence of that community needs to be tempered with a sense of imminent peril. Those codes must be kept out of Trump’s hands, no matter what.

Because Trump is, quite plainly, bonkers. Full disclosure, this is not a clinical diagnosis. ‘Bonkers’ is a word that lives comfortably in the rich vocabulary of madness, from the clinical to the slangy. When speaking of Trump, is ‘bonkers’ any less valid than ‘narcissistic’ or ‘sociopathic’? We don’t need a psychotherapist to tell us what we can see with our own eyes.

Not that there aren’t, indeed, a number of mental health professionals sounding the alarm. Possibly the most vocal is Dr. John Gartner, who has been watching Trump for years. Fully aware of the ethical dilemma, he has sought validation in numbers, consulting with dozens of his peers:

I asked several highly specialized experts about Trump's use of language, and they told me that what Trump is doing in total, but especially the phonemic paraphasias, were almost certain evidence of brain damage…Trump is evidencing formal thought disorder, where his basic ability to use language is breaking down.

We know that the press coverage of Trump’s rallies has been dishonestly edited down to the least objectionable soundbites, but from Gartner’s perspective, a lot more has been removed:

[The media] are consistently not showing the parts of Trump’s speeches and interviews where his eyes go blank, his jaw goes slack, he looks confused, and slurs words, uses non-words, can't finish a sentence, rambles, perseverates, confabulates and babbles incoherently.

As with all things Trump, there’s danger in revealing the truth. In canvassing his fellow psychologists, Gartner encountered a different sort of reticence, unrelated to their ethical strictures. While many were happy to share their observations with him, they were not willing to attach their names:

Each of these experts convinced me they weren’t being paranoid when they believed there was a good chance they would lose their jobs if they went on the record, not to mention other forms of retaliation, especially for those who live in red states.

This is not unique to the psychology field. If Trump were to win the election, no science — or scientist — would be safe from political and religious interference.

Meanwhile, Trump’s on-camera appearances have grown increasingly weird, a strange mashup of nonsensical ramblings, bizarre fantasies of sharks and batteries, and a firehose of lies that are over-the-top even for him. It’s getting hard even for Republicans to ignore this.

But unlike the great megalomaniacs of the past, Trump has lived his life in front of cameras, which, it turns out, have yielded an enormous amount of data about both the content and style of his speaking. This data can be measured against that of other public figures.

James Pennebaker, a social psychologist at the University of Texas, has done just that. He reviewed transcripts of Trump’s interviews, from between 2015 and 2024, and what he found was startling, if not exactly surprising.

Over that time, there was, in Trump’s speech:

“…a major rise in ‘all-or-nothing’ thinking which is signified by the use of words such as ‘completely,’ ‘never’ and ‘always’.”

Let me add to that list: “most ever,” “worst in our history,” “total disaster” — I’m sure we all have our favorites. This zero-sum, “all-or-nothing” thinking is, yes, well connected to dementia. But that’s not even the real eye-opener:

Pennebaker noted that a linguistic metric of analytic thinking reveals that Trump’s levels of complexity are remarkably low – most presidential candidates range between 60 and 70 in the metric, while Trump ranges from 10 to 24, something Pennebaker called “staggering.” “He does not think in a complex way at all.”

It’s hard to know if this lack of complexity is a symptom of cognitive decline, or if Trump is just truly stupid and always has been. Ultimately the answer doesn’t matter, because either way, it’s hugely alarming in its own right.

I am not the first to note that Trump’s mental decline might just be the untold story of this century. The prospect of a “mad king,” enabled by a Project 2025, capable of doing unlimited damage to the country and, indeed, the planet, would seem worth discussing in the media.

Likewise, the prospect of “regents” manipulating that mad king for their own corrupt purposes — the likes of Steve Bannon, Michael Flynn, Stephen Miller, and their cronies — running the country in Trump’s name.

Since the media seems content to leave this story untold, it’s up to others to tell it. It’s good to see the psychology community telling their side of it.

Comments

  1. To rural voters, who are the victims of a systematic takedown of their former way of life, even a madman who seems to support them is better than a sane option that they hold responsible for their situation. It matters not that the madman is the one who convinced them that the other guys caused their pain.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nice job. I think it always helps to add that Trump just plain SUCKS

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Making Sense — Or Not — of an Electoral Smackdown

I waited all night for bad news. I was Charlie Brown, certain that Lucy would yank the football away at the last second. Last Tuesday is still too big to grasp at this time, so I’m going to string together a few random thoughts, none of which would add up to a full essay. I’ll try to focus on things I’m not seeing much of in the media. The pundits are arguing about whether this epic smackdown was about the Iran war, which it was. Or about gas prices, which it also was. Or about tariffs, healthcare, inflation, ICE, or massive corruption. And yes, the list is long. But they’re all looking at the trees. The forest was Donald Trump. Or should I say the forest fire? He was the only thing on the ballot, a monster loose upon the land. Tuesday was a primal scream, ten years in the making, a scream rising from the monster’s victims, which all of us are. Tuesday was pure rage at the gall of this deranged narcissist for taking a flawed but functional country and deliberately wrecking it...

Abdul El-Sayed Plays MAGA Bingo with Mike Rogers

   If it had been a prize fight, they’d have stopped it in the early rounds. The final Michigan Senate debate between Abdul El-Sayed and Mike Rogers was hardly the mano-a-mano blood sport the press would have you believe, but plenty of mud — or a mud-like substance — was slung, all from one side of the aisle. It’s well  worth watching . Rogers tried mightily to get people with weak minds to see El-Sayed as a terrorist monster bent on jihad from the Senate floor. Which, sad to say, is a lie that lands easily in certain Michigan circles. There are still, for instance, a shocking number of misguided Jews who insist on feeling threatened by him, and for no rational reason. Let’s now stipulate that the Muslim Brotherhood is not exactly top-of-mind for most Michiganders, but it’s all Rogers had to work with. His was not an easy hand to play, especially with the Trump stink wafting off him, but he played it badly nonetheless. He was flustered, ill-informed, ...

MTG and the Rebranding of the GOP

   This piece is from November of last year, when the House “discharge petition” was gathering steam, ultimately forcing Trump's DOJ to release the Epstein files. This was a big deal at the time, though we’re still not much closer to the whole Epstein story. But that’s not why I’m re-running this. Rather, it’s to show that, even then, Republicans were starting to bail on Trump. Marjorie Taylor Greene is, of course, back in the news, still throwing kerosene on the dumpster fire currently consuming the GOP. In other words, her rebrand, which she started last year, has moved into a higher gear.   Last week began with Trump giving up on the Epstein files — yup, we heard about that on Monday. It ended Friday with Marjorie Taylor Greene announcing her resignation from Congress. Between those two bookends we got a blizzard of WTF moments, mostly centered around the snowballing Epstein scandal. What we seem to be witnessing, in real time, is the disintegratio...